Scroll through LinkedIn or Instagram and you see it almost every day: another new entrepreneur who has started their own "web agency". Everything custom, everything in-house. Branding, websites, apps, SEO, ads, AI chatbots, video. And whatever you ask, the answer is always: "Yes, absolutely!"

Sounds good. But what is actually behind it?

In many cases: someone with an AI tool, a subscription to a website builder and a healthy dose of self-confidence. There's nothing wrong with that as such, everyone starts somewhere. It only becomes a problem when you pay for it as if it were skilled work and find out later. So here are a few things to look out for.

All the websites look alike

This is usually the first thing you notice. A big headline in the middle, a vague gradient in the background, and below it three blocks with an icon and a short text. Look at the portfolio and you see the same trick for every client, just in a different colour.

That's no coincidence. AI tools work from what they have already seen thousands of times, so roughly the same thing comes out every time. A good website starts with your business, not with a template. A bakery and a law firm shouldn't look the same.

No real images

Look at the images. Often there are hardly any photos, or they are stock photos you'll also find on ten other sites. More and more often they are AI-generated images: just a bit too smooth, just a bit too perfect, with hands or text in the background that aren't quite right.

Real photos of a real team, a real workplace or real products take effort. That's exactly why they say something.

A logo that is really just text

Look at the agency's own logo. Is it just the company name in a standard typeface, without a symbol or anything of its own? Then probably nobody really thought about it.

Not every brand needs an icon, and a strong wordmark can work fine. But if an agency that wants to sell you a brand identity doesn't have one itself, that's remarkable to say the least.

Copy that says nothing

Read the copy out loud. "We take your brand to the next level." "Seamless digital experiences." "Results-driven and tailor-made." Sounds fine, but what does it actually say?

If you can swap the agency's name for that of any competitor and the text still works, it wasn't written for you. Probably not by a human either.

A portfolio without real clients

A portfolio full of nice mockups says little. What matters is whether those projects are actually live. Look the websites up. Do they exist? Do they work on your phone? Is it a real business? A few real clients say more than twenty fictional projects.

Always yes

An app? Yes. A webshop linked to your accounting? Yes. An AI chatbot, a rebrand and a campaign, done next week? Yes, absolutely.

Someone who can do everything usually can't do anything really well. A good partner asks questions first, sometimes says "I wouldn't do that" and refers you elsewhere when something falls outside their field. That may feel less pleasant in the first conversation, but it saves you a lot of trouble later.

Questions you can ask

In doubt? Ask these questions before you sign:

  • Can you show me a few websites that are live, for real clients?
  • Who exactly builds my website?
  • What happens if something breaks after delivery?
  • Who owns the website and the domain if we stop working together?
  • Why do you choose custom work here, and not an existing solution?

Do you get vague answers, or does the conversation quickly move past them? Then you know enough.

AI is not the problem

To be fair: using AI isn't wrong. I use it myself, like almost everyone in this field. The problem isn't the tool, but when there is nothing else behind it. No experience, no vision of their own, no idea what happens when things go wrong.

A good website is more than something that looks neat on day one. It has to fit your brand, keep working and be able to grow with your business. So look beyond the nice pictures and the enthusiastic "yes".